Dsg is def quicker and can be fun and better than mt in certain scenarios, but at the end of the day it wont keep you as involved with driving the car as a manual transmission will. Dsg is just a preferenceoptions and weather its better than manual or not is relative. Honda civic type r vs focus rs vs golf r vs leon cupra. The golf r with its awd is superior at launching, has a dsg, 25 hp more at 2k rpm less and even peak torque lasts quite short in our n. All of that said, the gti and golf r are both very technically capable cars. Dsg or manual vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. Given how similar the two cars are on paper, the difference could come down to transmission. Vw golf r vs audi s3 manual vs automatic drag race what difference does the gearbox make. Aug 08, 2018 in this video you will watch a vw golf r vs audi s3 drag race vw golf r from the racetrack directly to the road.
Theres almost nothing in this amg a45 vs golf r acceleration comparison. Im not saying a dsg is better than a manual, as i love my rabbit and miatas manual transmissions, but these are some nice benefits. Vw only had a dsg equipped golf r, whereas audi only offers the s1 with a manual box. I hate how d shifts too soon, i hate how s keeps the rpms at 3000 for what seems like a ridiculous amount of time before it up shifts, and s manual. So does the fastshifting dualclutch transmission allow the golf r. Aug 08, 2018 august 8, 2018 the honda civic type r and volkswagen golf r share specs but represent two different takes on what a hot hatch should be.
Hey guys, i know this topic has been discussed many times before but i want to put a twist to it. The premise of this video is to show you the performance difference you get between the vw group dualclutch automatic gearbox and the manual. Jan 16, 2018 get golf r manual vs dsg pdf file for free from our online library golf r manual vs dsg this particular pdf talk about the topic of golf r manual vs dsg, coupled with the whole set of supporting. We tested both back toback to determine which is better. Personally i think a dccequipped threedoor manual golf r. They examined the vw golf r mannequin with guide and dsg gearbox.
Despite a big power and price gap, the vw golf r seen here runs a mercedesamg a45 very close indeed. To illustrate this we effectively have two identical cars in terms of their engines and awd transmissions. We estimate that the dsg golf r will make the sprint to 60 in about 4. Apr 07, 2018 vw golf r vs audi s3 manual vs automatic drag race what difference does the gearbox make. In the video above, each model is fitted with volkswagens dsg dualclutch transmission and thus enjoys launch control. Manual golf r races auto audi s3, reveals some kind of. I assume this is related to supply and demand, as most people choose auto i think. With 1,181 used volkswagen golf r cars available on auto trader, we have the largest range of cars for sale available across the uk. Thestraightpipes staff gave a transparent reply to this query. Anyone regret buying a golf r in an auto vs manual.
A sixspeed manual transmission is standard with the golf r. The vw golf r with dsg and ford focus rs test their top. Have you driven a golf or sportwagen with the dsg yet. New renault megane rs vs honda civic type r vs volkswagen. He also points out that every time theyve drag raced a standard golf r. The 2019 is on paper down 4hp, and requires thinner oil 0w30 504. The formula changed little from the previous golf r. On the other hand, the civic type r is powered by a 310 horsepower 2liter turbo engine.
However, you can spec a dualclutch dsg gearbox, adding an extra gear in the process. May 19, 2016 1 smart fortwo humiliated by vw california camper van and atom 3. The honda doesnt belong in the same class as the i30, neither does the golf r to me. The 206kw380nm vw golf r has the advantage of more power and torque, but the 170kw370nm audi s1 counters with around 100kg less weight. It is a very advanced transmission, with positives and negatives. The volkswagen golf r is a very capable hot hatch, and in skilled hands it can beat everything from italian supercars to euro super sedans. The r is fast with dsg but with manual it just felt like any other car with me, lost the specialness that you should have with an r. The difference in weight between the manual and dsg box is almost exactly the same as the difference between a 2dr and 4dr. I was in the same boat a few years ago when buying a mk5 golf gti. The dealership near me has a 2017 golf r in a 6speed manual or i can order a 2018 with a dsg.
Well, while the video doesnt specify exactly which model caradvice has brought to the drag strip, closer inspection reveals that it is badged gti original, a basic threedoor model available down under in both manual and dsg form. Im just trying to find the time difference between manual and dsg for the quarter mile, and manual when no lift shifting vs dsg. Faster shifting than a manual transmission, the available 7speed dsg. This mannequin is basically nice, however this can be a nice take a look at and a transparent reply to the query who select transmission on this mannequin. In this video, we line up the latest volkswagen golf r with the latest golf gti for a good ol fashioned quartermile drag race. For me ive been a long time driver of manual cars and i really really wanted to love the manual mk7 r but when i test drove both i somehow felt the dsg.
The new sevenspeed dsg is smoother than the outgoing version at slow speeds, but when i first clicked the paddle it was a little slow to react. Considering a subaru wrx sti, ford focus rs, honda civic type r, mercedesamg gla45. Indeed, while the new polo gti churns out a healthy 147 kw, the golf gti in performance guise offered in europe delivers the fullfat 183 kw. Apr 07, 2018 manual golf r races auto audi s3, reveals some kind of problem. The 2019 vw golf r is trackinspired with a turbocharged engine, while also providing an equally sophisticated ride. Although vws dsg dualclutch automated manual is a good, reasonably sporty automatic, it is still an.
To find out were pitting the new renault megane rs against our reigning champion, the honda civic type r, and volkswagens freshly tweaked golf r. I was adamant my next car was going to be manual, i test drove a manual r then a dsg r and for me fell in love with the dsg. Audi s3 vs volkswagen golf r drag race audi lovers. Vw golf r dsg v manual video 12 may 2010 they main problem with the manual, in this rather pointless 060 exercise, is that second gear doesnt take you to 60, which is a bit odd.
Hi guys, i know this topic is done to death week in and week out but was wondering if anyone had any regrets with their choice of transmission they ended up with for their golf. The wrxs 3year36,000mile basic warranty expires 3 years and 36,000 miles sooner. The capabilities that you get between normal drive mode, sport, manual shifting, etc. Were guessing the publication chose a stickshift for the race. The golf r s corrosion warranty is 5 years longer than the wrxs 10 vs.
While true that no clutch upgrade is required, and that the dsg is faster, the dsg option generally costs more or similar to the clutch upgrade on a manual so youre paying either way before you. I ignored that stat when selecting a manual r, but, i am intrigued to understand what could account a reduction in a 060 time of. Theres almost nothing in this amg a45 vs golf r acceleration. The biggest thing i noticed w the dsg that i missed was the ability to cruise w the clutch in when coming up to a stop or something. Manual golf r races auto audi s3, reveals some kind of problem. Vw golf r vs audi s3 manual vs automatic drag race what. Alright, so back when i was looking around i tried the mk6 and mk7 of both the gti and golf r, with a mix of the dsg and 6mt transmissions.
Dec 23, 2016 this is the new, more powerful vw golf r. I know the dsg is faster, but it didnt exactly wow me when i test drove it, and it lugged the engine in d just like my wifes 2018 gsw dsg does. Honda has the civic type r, fords focus rs is worth having a look at, then theres the renault megane r. Manual vs dsg hi all, looking to get my first golf specifically r or gti, ive always driven manuals and love the ability to control the car but clearly the appeal of the dsg has got me curious. So does the fastshifting dualclutch transmission allow the golf r to outrun the focus rs in a straight line from 0 to 100 kmh and then from 0 to 250 kmh. Having driven a manual for 30 years i still occasionally reach for the clutch pedal out of instinct. Vw golf r which hot hatch will win in an awesome drag race put together by top gear. In fact i go as far as saying more than half the golf r cars local to me in my price range were dsg. Yes, one is the golf r and the other the audi s3 thats. For me i was almost on the fence bw choosing manual or dsg until i found out canadian dsg. The golf r comes with a full 6year72,000mile basic warranty, which covers the entire car.
Top gear drag races golf r, gti and gtd with predictable results. Both are superior in their performance and both cost way more than the n. For right now, only one car in all of north america can be purchased with vws sevenspeed, dualclutch dsg transmission and it is, of course, the golf r. The revised ea888 new injectors, variable cam lift and an electronically controlled turbo wastegate now makes 2kw380nm. I might be able to trade in my 2016 golf r 6sp manual for a 2019 golf r dsg, while keeping the same monthly payments. The golf r is equipped with a dsg gearbox, which makes it the fastest car ever made by volkswagen. That awkward moment when you have thoughts of regret when purchasing your manual 4 weeks ago if anyone wants a manual and isnt happy with the dsg get in touch emoji23 anyone else owned both versions and which did they prefer and why.
One of these is the best hothatch in america honda and vw push smallcar performance to the max in two practical. Volkswagen golf r used cars for sale on auto trader uk. Time for two very different takes on the hothatch formula to face off. I tested both the manual and dsg prior to purchasing my mk7 r and found the wife found the dsg to be a little more suited to our needs considering the wife occasionally wants to have a steer. The two questions below are talking about 14 mile times. I wanted a manual and wasnt at all interested in dsg. I have mkvi fixed typo gti with stage ii tuning and dsg, my friend has a new jetta with the new motor and stage i with manual tranny and he drove my gti last night and loves it and regrets getting the manual. Golf r with the sixspeed manual launches from 062 in 5. The audi s3 and vw golf r have the same power output, but theyre not equal in a drag race, especially when equipped with a different transmissions. The dsg has a different feel then a traditional torque converter style automatic. Manual vs dsg vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. With the update to the golf family comes a new transmission, straight from the skunkworks in wolfsburg. Is the vw golf r better with a manual or automatic gearbox.
929 884 1020 1386 1216 392 1016 694 858 613 589 196 574 460 1030 348 850 921 892 552 275 334 1043 714 1179 696 1258 120 587 165 845 366 80 1253